Substance dualism: do Descartes arguments work? Michael Lacewing

Substance dualism: do Descartes arguments work? Michael Lacewing [email protected] .uk Descartes divisibility argument The body is extended in space; it has (literal) parts. The mind has no (literal) parts. Leibnizs law of the indiscernibility of

identicals: If X and Y are the same thing, then they have the same properties Therefore, if X and Y have different properties, they are not the same thing Therefore, mind and body are different. Objections Mental illness and theories of the unconsciousness suggest that the mind does have parts Reply: bodies are spatially divisible, but minds are only

functionally divisible On the divisibility of the body Is it always true to say that something physical has parts? Could the smallest physical things not be divided in principle, e.g. force fields? But we can still talk of them having half the size This depends on the best theory of space If not all physical things are divisible,

then the fact that the mind isnt divisible doesnt show that it isnt physical Am I a substance? I think - is there an I? What does this mean? If I exist - as a substance - from one thought to the next, Descartes has not shown this; only that there are thoughts. If I exist as that which thinks this thought, Descartes has not shown I exist for more than one thought.

Obj: The second premise assumes that the mind is a substance Perhaps minds arent divisible because there are no minds only mental properties Descartes conceivability argument It is conceivable that mind can exist without body. Therefore, it is possible that mind can exist without body.

Therefore, mind and body are distinct substances. What is conceivable may not be possible Just because Descartes can think of his mind existing without his body, this doesnt mean that his mind really can exist without his body. What is conceivable is not always possible I think the Masked Man robbed the bank; I dont think my father robbed the bank; therefore, my father isnt the Masked Man. In one sense, it is possible that my father is not

the Masked Man. But if, unknown to me, my father is the Masked Man, then it is impossible that my father is not the Masked Man. Conceivability and possibility From conceiving that two people are distinct, we cant infer that they are distinct. Perhaps this applies to mind and body Reply: when we clearly and distinctly conceive of two things as distinct, then we can infer that they are distinct

Clear and distinct conception can establish possibility, e.g. all triangles must have angles that add up to 180 Masked Man: not clear and distinct; mind and body: clear and distinct Possibility and reality Suppose it is possible that the mind can exist as a distinct substance. Does this show that it is a distinct substance? If we can conceive of the mind and body as not distinct, e.g. that the mind is the thinking part of something extended, then it also seems possible

that the mind is not a substance So which is it? Descartes must show not only that it is possible for the mind to be independent of the body, but that it is impossible for it to be dependent on the body Is mental substance conceivable? What makes it possible for me to think I think? Perhaps we become confused when

conceiving of mind as distinct from the body Logical behaviourism: To talk of mental states is to talk of how something behaves But without a body, how can something exhibit behaviour? A mental state is something that only a physical substance can have

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Keys to Successful Family Life I. What are

    Keys to Successful Family Life I. What are

    It is not a time for squabbling between mom and dad. d. It is not a time for the latest gossip. e. It is a time to affirm and fellowship with one another. ... Do we teach our children to...
  • Life Course Theory

    Life Course Theory

    The Life Course Approach FROM THEORY TO COMMUNITY PRACTICE Faye Johnson Project Director The Magnolia Project July 9, 2014 Policy brief: A new agenda for MCH policy and programs-integrating a life course perspective by Amy Fine, Milt Kotelcheck, Nancy Adess...
  • Using the States Accounting Procedures Manual and the

    Using the States Accounting Procedures Manual and the

    More accounts may be necessary to assist in budgeting and analysis. Michigan Chart of Accounts-detail "Balance Sheet accounts (Assets, Liabilities, and Equity) are always "000" for the middle grouping of account numbers.
  • LWW PPT Slide Template Master

    LWW PPT Slide Template Master

    Assumption: Cultures guide the way people structure their experiences. Ethnography (cont.) Seeks an emic perspective (insider's view) of the culture Relies on wide range of data sources (interviews, observations, documents; some may be quantitative.) Participant observation is a particularly important...
  • Social Determinants of Health - Florida Department of Health

    Social Determinants of Health - Florida Department of Health

    Social conditions are environments, norms, and patterns of social control that are health-promoting or health-damaging. Social conditions influence the development of psychosocial resources, which help to protect against ill-health, morbidity, and mortality.
  • Where is the Universe?

    Where is the Universe?

    Inflation Dark Matter: The Evidence 'Peculiar' motion of stars (Oort) Coma cluster (Zwicky) ClusterSim Galaxy rotation GalRot Galaxy clusters Superclusters Dark Matter: What is it? Baryonic MACHOs Planets Brown dwarfs Red dwarfs Black holes Hot gas Non-Baryonic HDM Neutrinos CDM...
  • TVT ja verkko-opetus - eNorssi

    TVT ja verkko-opetus - eNorssi

    Muuta ajankohtaista. TVT-strategioiden tilannekatsaus. Lähitavoitteet haasteiden voittamiseksi (infrastruktuuri, tunnushallinto yms.). Kysely toteutetaan e-lomakkeella (Jari S, Tuomo T, Mikko H ja Päiviö) viimeistään toukokuun puolessa välissä -> yhteinen kooste
  • מצגת של PowerPoint

    מצגת של PowerPoint

    לימודים במשך סמסטר סתו 2010 באוניברסיטת McGill קנדה http://www.mcgill.ca/