Hypercube Ltd. Conceptual Ontology Engineering Tutorial Session 3:

Hypercube Ltd. Conceptual Ontology Engineering Tutorial Session 3: The Data Dimension; Top Level Ontologies Mike Bennett FOIS JOWO Cape Town, South Africa September 2018 1 Session 3 The Data Dimension Introducing Top Level ontology (Upper Ontology)

Some popular TLOs The Data Dimension Introducing data to ontology Things versus Strings Truth makers and data surrogates What about real things that are data? Information kinds versus datatypes Values modeling

Introducing Data to Ontology Things Information Type A set specification for a kind of Independent Thing that generalizes all towers (e.g., a tall narrow structure) A set specification for a kind of Dependent Continuant that is a record structure containing tower

observations (e.g., a TOWER table or a #Tower class) Sets One of many sets of independent things that generalize all towers One of many sets of dependent continuant record structures containing tower observations (e.g., in that database there) Member

A member of zero or more sets A member of one or more sets of of all towers (E.g., the actual one record structures containing tower we call the Eiffel Tower) observations (E.g., one that represents the actual Eiffel Tower) Represents #tower123 Jim Logan, NoMagic Data surrogate versus Real Things Look for signatures in data that imply the presence of real world, identifying matter

Frame the necessary conditions for membership of a class (in a logical ontology) in terms of what would be found (true) in data when the class of thing is there Inference as distinct from meaning in the original sense From the data you can infer that a thing exists in reality Real meaning by definition mostly does not rely on data! Examples Meaning of Bank: framed in terms of legal capabilities and rights Data surrogate: banking license Ownership and Control Confer certain rights and involve certain capabilities These are social constructs not data Data surrogates: documents, deeds, shares etc.

6 Conceptual and Physical Ontologies Business Conceptual Ontology (CIM) Business The Language Interface Extract and Optimise Technology Operational Ontology (PSM) 7

Types and Datatypes Data types Business Conceptual Ontology (CIM) Business The Language Interface Extract and Optimise Technology Data types

Operational Ontology (PSM) Platform specific matter 8 Data as Real Things There are also things in the real world that are made of information Information Construct as a high level class of Thing Names, publicly issued IDs, ratings, codes, documents, messages etc. These are on the real world side of the Rhombus

There will also be data about these 9 Other implications Names: Name as an ontological class of thing Name as text Dates and Times Temporal matter XSD datatypes for Date, DateTime etc. What is Date? Value Types 10

Data: The T Box aboutThings the data is about Data-centric Intensions Datarepresents focused Extensions 11 Data Delta about represents

DD Things the data is about Data-focused Extensions The Real Things 12 Data Delta: => 0 => 0 about

Things the data is about represents DD => 0 The Real Things 13 Information Kinds

Names Textual material Dates and Times Yes or No (or maybe) Numbers Whole numbers Numbers with decimal places Positive Numbers Fractions Percentages

URL Pictures Sounds Words Letters And many more Datatypes Text Restricted text

Unrestricted text Dates and Times Boolean Numeric datatypes Integer Float Positive integer, positive float URL/URI Other information kinds are rendered in files, for example vector graphics, rich text, video and sound formats Relating information kinds to datatypes Different kinds of information need to be stored in a computer

Datatypes determine how these are stored for optimum memory usage XML datatypes differ on this, in that textual conventions are used to render different datatypes, which must then be translated to application datatypes for processing if needed Numeric datatypes allow for arithmetic calculations on the data Textual datatypes allow for alphanumeric sorting Implications for Ontologies OWL ontologies use a rather restricted sub-set of the XML datatypes set These are chosen in line with operational constraints on reasoner applications These constraints have no place in a conceptual ontology We need to translate real world kinds of information into OWL XML

datatypes for any onward processing in operational ontology applications Just we also will if using the ontology to derive applications in other architectures Also a conceptual ontology must be presented to the business for validation in their own terms SMEs not only do not know about technical datatypes, they officially dont care! Lets look at some example comparisons Names A name identifies a person or a thing A name typically consists of a set of sounds and a corresponding set of letters making up the spoken word which is that persons name Translating to datatypes Names are generally rendered as textual datatypes,

often with a length limitation to suit the application Scotlands Missing Letter The Scots alphabet has one more letter than the English alphabet Yogh: This never made it onto the typewriter and so is missing in the ASCII character set and many others Notes from http://www.omniglot.com/writing/scots.htm The last letter, usually referred to as yogh, still appears in Scots personal and place names, though is usually written Z z. This has lead to the spelling-based pronunciations of names like Menzies [mnziz] - should be [ms], Dalziel [dj] and Monzie [mne] Names: Some edge cases

The Artist Formally Known as the Artist Formerly Known as Prince Name rendered as a symbol only Music press shortcut (using ASCII): "Prince changed his name to the unpronounceable glyph O(+> in 1993, which he used until 2000. During that time, he was more frequently referred to as "the artist formerly known as Prince," and his new symbol was not embraced by most fans." Answers and Booleans Business (reality) There are certain kinds of question for which the answer is Yes or No Yes, No, Maybe Yes, No, Maybe, dont know, it isnt as simple as that

Some propositions necessarily require a binary answer Is today Wednesday only has two valid answers The dont know option is covered under the Open World Assumption Others do not Computer A boolean returns the truth value of a proposition Usually a good match for many of these question types It does not mean strictly the same thing though Many data sources use booleans where a binary choice of values exist in the data Contract: isNegotiable (boolean) It either is or it isnt. Dates and Times Business (reality)

A date is simply an index to a day The first of September 2014 6 Elul, 5774 The day I wrote this slide The calendar is the scheme which defines that index Computer Date DateTime OWL DateTime only (for some egregious reason) Therefore the data which is fed in has to have values set as midnight (making them

indistinguishable from things that actually happen at dead of night) Values Core Definitions (JCGM 200:2008) Quantity : property of a phenomenon, body, or substance, where the property has a magnitude that can be expressed as a number and a reference Value of a quantity: value number and reference together expressing magnitude of a quantity Also DOLCE/Guizzardi Quale Measurement unit (unit of measurement unit) :real scalar quantity, defined and adopted by convention, with which any other quantity of the same kind can be compared to express Kind of quantity (quantity kind): aspect common to mutually

comparable quantities Also DOLCE /Guizzardi Quality Space Why Model Values, Quantities and Units? Many models have int and String as the types of Characteristics of things Values have semantics beyond their representation as strings or numbers

E.g. a social security number has source, uniqueness and identity implications E.g. An exchange rate on the London and N.Y. exchanges are not the same Programming example: Assigning a description (string) to a name (string) is an error. Examples of unit confusion are well known

This does not represent their semantics, only how they are represented in the computer E.g. First mars lander crashes due to unit confusion When consuming, federating or translating data it is dangerous to be unsure what the data represents Different representations of the same concepts may use or expect different units expressed in different ways So to federate, integrate and translate value kinds & units as well as the concepts they represent must be clear and consistent across independent models But, specifying units in conceptual reference models is over-commitment and ignores local needs and conventions Making values, quantities and units first class in a language encourages use and consistency. Using the MDA (Model Driven Architecture) pattern allows implementation diversity

libraries of common value types and units allows for interoperability and reuse Quantity Kinds & Units in SMIF Profile 02/02/2020 For numeric characteristics, we want to know what it means (e.g. Temperature), not the kind

of number (Real). <> is an aspect common to mutually comparable quantities represented by one or more units. A unit value represents a quantity kind, there are multiple units representing temperature. A physical representation would then represent the unit as some kind of number in a specified unit. Threat & Risk 26 Data represents concept

Mapping Rule Represents STIX XSD Green line is Represents Concepts Rules specify mapping details 11/18/2015 OMG Threat & Risk for STIDS 2015 27

Conceptual Extensions Mid Level Ontologies Domain independent concepts Reusable Semantics from other domains Aim to identify and re-use available academic work on conceptual abstractions where these exist Subject to their fitting within the same set of theories as your conceptual ontology (or adapt as needed) A considerable body of such work exists in the applied ontology field Hypercube 2015 28

Semantic Abstractions Inevitable by-product of the What kind of Thing is this? question Ontologies are built around a classification hierarchy (Taxonomy) of kinds of thing This is key to meaningful ontologies Enables disambiguation across business contexts Not a technology activity Examples: Contract, Credit, Asset etc. Hypercube 2015 29 Semantics Re-use Research and identify re-usable content semantics

In formal published ontologies Business models in non ontological (non FOL) formats Technical / messaging standards to reverse engineer into semantics Pre-requisite: identify abstractions needed to support the specification concepts Examples: Transaction semantics Legal / contractual etc. Real Estate (for mortgage loans) Hypercube 2015 30 Upper Ontology Examples

Independent Relative and Mediating Things Continuant and Occurrent things Others Approaches to Context 1. Context as a Class Mediating Thing partition 2. Kinds of Context Who What When Where hoW Why? 3. Everything as Context Upper ontologies Overview

Partitions v Geometries Relative Things (qua entities) Time sensitive things General UO choices Oher partitions Information construct Dispositions, other philosophical stuff we probably dont need Partitioning

In general there seem to be 2 things to consider with top level ontologies: How the world (the domain if discourse) is divided up: Partitions How these concepts are framed: Treatments 4D v3D / 3D+ Endurantism v perdurantism Mereology (parts and wholes) Dimensions, values, quantities etc.

Stance Consider the ontological stance of the ontology Possible stances (not exhaustive) Realist: the ontology only represents things that have some extension in time and space in some real or possible world Idealist: Ontology must be able to represent concepts whether or not these have physical or temporal extent For risk, business planning, commitments etc. concepts are essential Risk event is avoided in any world in which it is a risk event Plans, commitments, Prescriptive processes etc. Realism may also include social constructs

Relative Things Added Pontoon This is another thing you can land a boat on Some jetties you cant land or unload, they are just for managing tidal currents What jetties are for versus what they are What pontoons are for (always built fo that purpose) What does it mean to be something defined by its function: Landings a Relative Thing Upper Ontology Partitions 38

The Relatives Partition Everything which may be defined falls into one of three categories: Thing Independent Thing Relative Thing Thing in Itself Thing in some context

e.g. some Person e.g. that person as an employee, as a customer, as a pilot Mediating Thing Context in which the relative things are defined

e.g. employment, sales, aviation 39 Definitions: Sowa Independent categories are characterized by monadic predicates defined in terms of some entity x by itself (including its inherent parts and properties) and not in terms of anything external to x. Relative categories are characterized by dyadic predicates that relate an entity x to some external entity y that can exist independently of x. Mediating categories are characterized by triadic or higher predicates that show how an entity x mediates two or

more entities (y,z, . . .) and thereby establishes new relationships among them. Definitions: FIBO Conceptual Framework Independent Thing: a thing in its own right Relative Thing: A thing defined specifically and only in relation to some context. Mediating Thing: A thing which brings together two or more independent things into some relation, usually resulting in their being defined as Relative Things. The Relatives Partition Thing Independent

Thing Person Mediating Thing (context) Relative Thing Employee Customer Pilot Employment

Sales Aviation played by relationship: That which performs the role of the Relative Thing 42 The Relatives Partition Thing Independent Thing

Person Mediating Thing (context) Relative Thing Employee Customer Pilot Employment

Sales Aviation In context relationship: Context in which the Independent Thing performs the role of the Relative Thing 43 The Relatives Partition Thing Independent Thing

Person Mediating Thing (context) Relative Thing Employee played by Customer Pilot Employment

Sales Aviation In context Everything which may be defined falls into one of these three categories In order to complete a model of business terms and definitions, all three are needed This extends beyond conventional ontology applications into a full and legally nuanced conceptual ontology 44 Subsequent Refinement Thing In context

played by Independent Thing Relative Thing Mediating Thing (context) Actually playedBy relation may sometimes be another Relative Thing inContextOf is sometimes an Independent Thing

Promoted both to Thing Comparable with BFO Not all contexts are Mediating Thing 45 Mediating Thing as Context Not all relative things are relative to a thing that we would consider as a mediating thing, but contexts always create relative things Mediating Thing is one kind of context in that it brings together 2 or more things in defined roles or functions Includes business areas, process workflow, customer ad client relationships etc.

Hierarchy of Contexts: Pilot Person played by Pilot Commercial Pilot Pilot of M101 John played by

Your pilot today In context In context In context In context Aviation Commercial Aviation

Flight MH101 Flight MH101 on 18 Oct 2017 Hierarchy of Contexts: Customer Legal Person played by Natural Person Bank Client Retail Customer

In context Bank Client Relationship Retail Customer Relationship Organization Current Account Holder Loan Borrower Current Account Relationship

Loan Relationship Ontology Partitioning 2 Continuant and occurrent Things Also known as Endurant and Perdurant Ref: Guarino and Welty Ontology Partitioning 2 Thing Continuan t Occurrent Ontology Partitioning 2

Thing Continuan t Occurrent Continuant: where it exists Occurrent: the concept it exists in all its parts is only meaningful with Even if these change over time reference to time Ontology Partitioning 2 Thing

Continuant Person Contract Occurrent Pilot Event State Etc.

Continuant: where it exists Occurrent: the concept it exists in all its parts is only meaningful with Even if these change over time reference to time Ontology Partitioning 2 Thing Continuant Person Contract

Occurrent Pilot Event State Etc. Things which are independent or relative are also either continuant or occurrent Ontology Partitioning 2 Example Thing

Continuant Me Me: where I exist I exist in all my parts Even if these change over time Occurrent My life My life: happens over a period of time and

cannot be defined without time Ontology Partitioning 3 Thing Concrete Abstract Ontology Partitioning 3 Thing Concrete Abstract Concrete: A physical Abstract: the concept is

only meaningful as an thing Or a virtual thing in some reality abstraction from reality Ontology Partitioning 3 Thing Concrete Pillar of Stone Financial Instrument

Abstract Wheelbarrow Goal Resolution Desire Not as simple as physical v non physical Concrete: not limited to 3D physical reality Abstract: no physical or virtual expression

Some Popular Upper Ontologies 58 Sowa KR Lattice Sowa Partitions (FIBO * and Semantic Shed) * Developed as part of conceptual framework for FIBO but not published as part of the FIB 60

DOLCE TUpperWare A View on GFO Ontology Summit 2018, Feb 07 63 YAMATO IDEAS GIST


GRANULARITY ORGAN AND ORGANISM Organism (NCBI Taxonomy) Anatomica l Entity (FMA, CARO) Organ Function

(FMP, CPRO) CELL AND CELLULAR COMPONENT Cell (CL) Cellular Compone nt (FMA, GO) Cellular

Function (GO) MOLECULE Molecule (ChEBI, SO, RnaO, PrO) Phenotypic Quality (PaTO) Molecular Function (GO)

Biological Process (GO) Molecular Process (GO) ~2005 initial OBO Foundry suite 68 Questions? Next: Deep dive into some upper ontology partitions

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Linux Device Model and Sysfs - Arizona State University

    Linux Device Model and Sysfs - Arizona State University

    a driver to manage a gpio chip. a mouse to behave as an input device. To support. Power . management and . system shutdown. Communications with user . space. Hotpluggable. devices. Device . classes. Object lifecycles
  • Objective 11/19/15: Provided notes SWBAT Discuss the history

    Objective 11/19/15: Provided notes SWBAT Discuss the history

    Circadian Rhythm. Our 24 hour biological clock. Our body temperature & awareness changes throughout the day. It is best to take a test or study during your circadian peaks. How can the circadian rhythm help explain . jet lag? Circadian....
  • Vietnam - Pennsylvania State University

    Vietnam - Pennsylvania State University

    1992 Vietnam signed a 1976 ASEAN agreement on regional amity and cooperation, regarded as the first step towards ASEAN membership 1996 ASEAN membership 1992 Vietnam established diplomatic relations with South Korea 1995 Vietnam and the United States agreed to exchange...
  • Who am I meant to be? In search of a psychological account of ...

    Who am I meant to be? In search of a psychological account of ...

    McGeer (2004) - Theories based upon the notion of a 'lack of empathy' are based on a one-sided asymmetrical view of two people failing to understand one another. Lack of awareness of self and others shown to be untrue when...
  • Warm Up Why was the Mt. St. Helens

    Warm Up Why was the Mt. St. Helens

    Mount St. Helens - Composite Volcano (Stratovolcano) in Washington State. Erupted in 1980 after being dormant - "inactive" for 120 years. North face of mountain experiences largest ever recorded debris landslide. Pyroclastic flow from eruption destroyed 230 square miles. 57...
  • bloodborne pathogens training - DePaul University

    bloodborne pathogens training - DePaul University

    Do not attempt to provide first aid beyond your training. Warn others if they are getting too close or attempting to provide first aid, as they may not be aware of the risks. Respond promptly and appropriately to situations that...
  • Strengthen the Hands

    Strengthen the Hands

    Isaiah affirms, "The Everlasting God, the Lord, the Creator of the ends of the earth does not become weary or tired… He gives strength to the weary…" and "those who wait for the Lord will gain new strength," mounting up...
  • La crise de cuba - LeWebPédagogique

    La crise de cuba - LeWebPédagogique

    La peur du nucléaire (course aux armements) et le poids de la dissuasion permettent d'éviter un affrontement direct , un affrontement atomique. 2. La crise de Cuba, un tournant dans la guerre froide puisque s'ouvre ensuite une période de détente