The return of Industrial Policy Turins Conference September 2006 Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 1 Contents Introduction- Industrial policy : another come back, Why? 1- Industrial Policy Definition, clarification, 2- Old models of Ind. Policy : the french case 3- The failures of the European model 4- Patterns of the new french model Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 2
Introduction : Industrial policy , the eternal come back Dead concept 5 years ago when everybody was celebrating the new economy , the new spirit of entrepreneurship The use of the terms Ind.Po obsolete since Maastricht treaty which gave ind.py the kiss of death and today its like a phenix revival, why? 3 reasons, historical, theoretical and political 1- A classical debate in times of crisis of low growth After WW2 Reconstruction the American challenge After 1974 The Japanese chalenge Today Chinindia 2- A renewed theoretical debate New thinking in economic development theories : competitive advantages are built Outsourcing Offshoring and a renewed debate on free trade 3
The european debate : what went wrong ? The poor european growth performance: Failure of horizontal policies (competitive environment policies) The Lisbonne fiasco Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 3 Theortetical debate 1 Outsourcing, offshoring and a renewed debate on trade Offshoring & outsourcing : The big fear Industry Research Services In an open economy, in a free trade world =>losers and winners (regions, sectors, categories of skills etc) but what if all the losers are in the same side , what if an immiseration process is developing Bhagwati/Samuelson Issues of technology transfer to China. China as the leader in high tech exports
India from call centers to Business process oursourcing Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 4 theoretical debate 2 : Industrial policy for the XXIst century : Market failures gave the rationale for industrial policy Import substitution policies State ownership Strategic planning Government failures laid the foundations of the Washington consensus and consequently of a hands off policy : state cant pick up the winners, he may be captured and there is a problem of allocative efficiency
Three theoretical reasons for targeted sectoral industrial policies To solve coordination problems, the state must build appropriate institutions Information and R&D Externalities have an inpact on productivity Existence of high initial costs to enter certain markets and lack of financial resources due to risks and time frame (ex Airbus) Reality is the only judge (D.Rodrik) Import substitution, planning and state ownership did produce some successes Over time they may lead to colossal failures and crises Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 5
Vertical and horizontal policies In contrast to general business environment policies that have an indirect impact on industryincluding macroeconomic and social polices, as well as capital equipment and national defence policiesindustrial policy in the strict sense is a sectoral policy; it seeks to promote sectors where intervention should take place for reasons of national independence, technological autonomy, failure of private initiative, decline in traditional activities, and geographical or political balance. Depending on the country and the variety of capitalism there, any existing sectoral policy is the responsibility of the state (directly or indirectly), public banks, or local authorities. Sectoral policy (for ex in the bio-tech sector) can be achieved by means of horizontal policies (cluster policy) when the agregation factor plays the key role Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 6 Part Two : Industrial policy of the past : the french case.
High tech colbertism The Grands Programmes Policy Public R&D and Public finance Offensive Protectionnism Agencies : Hybride bodies Administration & Entreprise Public procurement and national equipment projects National Champions (state owned in most cases) Coordination through a homogeneous elite (Grands corps) Lameduck policy Progressive attrition through subsidies and social benefits Restructuring with european help in certain cases Coal, Steel, National champions Fiscal and legal incentives but with state blessing This policy with its successes and failures shaped the french specialisation Alcatel & FT, Alstom & EdF, SNCF, Total, EADS, Sagem-Snecma, Thales, Thomson, Arcelor, Renault, Lagardere, STMicroelectronics, Cap . Bull, Normed, MFL (Machine Tool Industry) Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 7
A dirigist end to french dirigism New economic conditions : The Single market, the Maastricht treaty The WTO agreements, Horizontal policies instead of vertical industrial policies The dismantling of the state-led finance economy Disintermediation, universal banking, .. The big bang of 1984 Department of Industry = Grenelle Consulting Group End of the grands projets Globalisation of the french groups Deregulation of the big utilities which were at the heart of the french colbertist model EDF, FT, Elf Privatization Step 1 : failure of the rheineland bankled model The inverted control scheme, interlocking directorates, former statist oligarchy Privatisations step 2 : the adoption of a financial market led capitalism Proceeds of the privatizations 100 Billion euros, the american pension funds as the main holders of newly issued french equity Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO
8 Part 3 : The three stages of european industrial policy Principal stages of the European community since 1982 and how competition policy succeeded in disqualifying the industrial policy gradually. 1- The Davignon balance between Industrial policy(Esprit-Race -...) and the competition policies Esprit Race Brite Euram as means of industrial policy through precompetitive research programs 2- Maastricht or the dedication-prohibition of the industrial policy The Eureka initiative and the Failure of Eureka 95 (HDTV) 3- Policies of competitive environment. Policies designed to enhance competition through sound macroeconomic policies, a true internal market and proper incentives in the research field Referring to the Sapir Report, the Kok report, the Beffa Report, one can see that this policy was a failure if one judges by different criteria (rate of growth, evolution of specialization (high tech component) etc Elie COHEN
CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 9 Horizontal european industrial policies Competition is the best stimulus for innovation Research incentives Structural Market reforms Competition policy Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO Sound macroeco policy : IP policy
10 Part 4 The new french industrial policy Pression put on Brussels The big 3 letter to Prodi on Industrial policy The demand for an easing of rules of the Stability Pact for investments Horizontal policies Fiscal reform of the taxe professionnelle Social end of the 35 hours work week Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 11 Why? : the decline of french industry Erosion of the industrial base, Erosion of the french spcialisation in high tech products Industrial activity at a disatvantage Industry is more heavily taxed Industry is more socialy constrained
Industry suffers heavy regulations The distribution, services and banking sectors are less taxed and socialy constrained they enjoy better economic and financial situations Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 12 How? French U turn The collapse of the intervention state apparatus in the industry sector The privatisation of the state owned sector The end of public funding for equipment, exports, innovation, etc The end of the grands projets What was maintained a program in the nanotech field which absorbed 80% of the appropriations of Min of Industry (crdits non affects aux grands programmes digitip) = > Rules of WTO, UE aid policy, budgetary constraints, lack
of state expertise make impossible the true return of industrial policy Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 13 The new industrial policy The Chirac initiative : What problem do we have to adress ? 4 reports Beffas answer : lack of specialisation need of new grands programmes Blancs answer lack of coordination need of a cluster policy Deniss answer ecology of businee how can we help the growth of SMEs Cohens answer institutions designed for imitation policies dont fit when the challenge is innovation The new industrial policy the sum of diverse proposals with small amount of money Sectoral targeted policies : Beffa A2I Modle ARPA, NASA 10 programs in health, energy, environment, transportation, IT,
Clusters : Ples de comptitivit SME trageted measures: Oseo Sba Project oriented R&D : ANR Modele NSF Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 14 Conclusions There is an urgent need of an industrial policy in Europe This policy has to be multifaceted , it is not possible to maintain an exclusive horizontal policy Nation states can no longer afford a national sectoral policy in energy,
health, transportation etc.. But national governments can wreck the single market In designing its industrial policy the EU has to take into account the political economic arguments, its worthless to persue policies that cant deliver more growth and that are at the same time politically costly Innovation & research policies, higher education policies, european grands programmes like gallileo etc can deliver a double dividend in terms of growth and legitimacy. Cluster policies can do the same at the local level provided that their choice is based on sound economics and not red tape Elie COHEN CAE-CNRS-SciencesPO 15
Crucible tongs. Aluminum Foil. Refrigerator. For each trial. Cuvetteand cap . 1000 μLof 1 M sodium chloride solution. 3mL of colloidal gold. 100μL of the solution. VernierSpectro-vis. Vernier Logger Pro Software. 10 mL Graduated Cylinder. Micropipette. Thermometer.
Identify/Describe cell, tissue, organ, organ system, and organism. Distinguish between the differences among cells, tissues, organs, organ systems, and organisms. TODAYS DO We will watch a short video about and discuss the levels of cellular organization and complete a graphic...
Au Mexique, la compétition n'était pas aussi intense qu'ici. Plus on vieillit, plus il y a de la compétition et moins on joue pour le plaisir. Au secondaire, ou bien on joue très bien et on essaie de se faire...
A yellow legged rooster was crossed with a white legged hen. All fifteen of the offspring were yellow legged. What is the genotype of the rooster? Practice Test cross. Suppose you work for a company that sells plant seeds. You...
Written in the Context of 19th Century Utilitarianism (Bentham, Mill, practical utility) Addresses debate, still ongoing today, about the . purpose. and . role. of higher education: Pragmatic argument . for the "utility" of education (vocational training, skills, trades, financial...
Uncertainty analysis can be used to assist in the selection of equipment and procedures based on their relative performance and cost. Advanced-Stage and Single Measurement Uncertainty Analysis. Consider procedural and test control errors that affect the measurement
Portly (adj) (especially of a man) having a stout body; somewhat fat. Archaic-of a stately or dignified appearance and manner. President Teddy Roosevelt was . portly. in every sense of the word. Synonym: stout, heavy-set. Antonym: skinny
Ready to download the document? Go ahead and hit continue!