Intervening Variables - FACULTY

Intervening Variables Intervening variables are hypothetical internal states that are used to explain relationships between observed variables, such independent and dependent variables. Intervening variables are not real things. They are interpretations of observed facts, not facts themselves. But they create the illusion of being facts. EXAMPLE learning, memory, motivation, S: attitude, personality, traits, knowledge, understanding, thinking, expectation, intelligence, intention. Intervening Variables Not Real? Lets look again at the experiment by Tolman & Honzik (1930) on latent learning in rats, specifically, the group that received a reward every time they reached the goal box. One of the Independent Variables was the number of practice trials the rats received. They got 1 trial per day, so each rat got an increasing number

of trials. The Dependent Variable was the number of wrong turns (errors) that rats made on a trial. The following graph shows a relationship between the independent variable and the dependent variable. Tolman and Honzik, 1930 Practice Independent Trials Average 0 Errors 2 4 6 8 10 Variable

Errors Learnin Intervening g Dependent Variable Variable Theoretically, an internal state of learning intervened between the independent variable and the dependent variable. It was this state that caused errors to decrease, not the practice trials. 1 10 Trials (1 Trial per Day)

17 Operational Definitions Intervening variables are studied by means of operational definitions, which are descriptions of procedures that are assumed to have some link to the internal state. Operational Definition Practice Independent Trials Variable Learnin g Intervening Variable Operational Definition Errors Dependen

t Variable Operational Definitions Intervening variables have no existence apart from these observed variables. They are just words, interpretations of facts, like theories. Operational Definition Practice Independent Trials Variable Learnin g Intervening Variable Operational Definition Errors Dependen

t Variable Operational Definitions Circular Reasonin g As explanations of behavior, intervening variables can lead to an error in logic called circular reasoning in which you explain something in terms of itself and so dont get beyond the original facts. To avoid circular reasoning, you must have two or more operational definitions of the same internal state, and they must be correlated. Heres an example of circular reasoning that results from having just one operational definition. Operational Definitions GOAL Two rats receive a food reward when

they run from the Start box to the Goal box of a straight alley runway. They get an equal number of practice trials and run equally fast. One day, the rat on the left is observed to run much faster than the rat on the right. Circular Reasonin g GOAL Operational Definitions GOAL Why the difference in running speeds? You may want to explain it in terms of

motivation, defined as an internal state that causes an organism to move toward a goal. More specifically, you could say that the fast rat was hungrier than the slow rat. Circular Reasonin g GOAL Operational Definitions GOAL This is circular reasoning. It sounds like an explanation but it isnt. Running speed toward

a food reward is a legitimate operational definition of hunger. Its OK to infer different levels of hunger from running speeds, but its circular to then use hunger to explain those running speeds. Circular Reasonin g GOAL Operational Definitions Circular Reasonin g Running Speed

defines explain s X Hunger A second operational definition of hunger is needed to break this circle. Operational Definitions Running Speed defines Hunger defines Hours of Food Deprivation

Circular Reasonin g For example, the fast rat may have been deprived of food longer than the slow rat. Hours of food deprivation could be used as an operational definition of hunger. Operational Definitions Running Speed defines Hunger

defines Hours of Food Deprivation Circular Reasonin g Different levels of hunger could be inferred from the different periods of deprivation, and then these hunger levels could be used to explain the different running speeds without circularity. Operational Definitions Running

Speed defines Hunger defines Hours of Food Deprivation Circular Reasonin g The more operational definitions you have that are correlated with each other, the more useful would be the underlying

intervening variable. Operational Definitions Questionnaire Responses define Correlate d? Attitude defines Everyday Behavior Circular Reasonin g By this standard, how useful would

you say are the concepts of attitude, intelligence and personality trait? Observing Internal Events Intervening variables differ from other kinds of internal events that are real and can be directly observed. Conscious experiences are private events that are directly sensed by the individual and not open to observation by others, like self-talk, feelings, and sensations. Biological processes are open to observation by others using appropriate devices, like an EEG machine to measure electrical activity of the brain.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Barnsley Federation of Tenants and Residents Designated Tenant

    Barnsley Federation of Tenants and Residents Designated Tenant

    Berneslai Homes helped develop the process based on their existing 'Appeal Panel' process (which includes tenant representatives) 10 members recruited and trained March 13 Registered with the Housing Ombudsman Literature produced Live May 13 How it works… Panel of three....
  • Chapter 6 Population and Community Ecology Friedland and

    Chapter 6 Population and Community Ecology Friedland and

    The Exponential Growth Model. The exponential growth model. When populations are not limited by resources, their growth can be very rapid. More births occur with each step in time, creating a J-shaped growth curve.
  • Basic Skills Summer Institute August 2008 1 BSI

    Basic Skills Summer Institute August 2008 1 BSI

    Slide 14 2. What percent of the students in your class probably require additional pre-collegiate training in order to be successful in college-level course work? Need to think about this one 3. The definition of Basic Skills is: "Those foundational...
  • ILMU UKUR TANAH & PEMETAAN - Gunadarma

    ILMU UKUR TANAH & PEMETAAN - Gunadarma

    Pengantar Survey & Pemetaan Ilmu ukur tanah pada dasarnya terdiri dari tiga bagian besar yaitu : (lanjutan) Pengukuran Titik-titik Detail Pekerjaan Survey & Pemetaan Dalam perencanaan bangunan Sipil misalnya perencanaan jalan raya, jalan kereta api, bendung dan sebagainya, Peta merupakan...
  • Robustness in biology DNA self assembly is universal

    Robustness in biology DNA self assembly is universal

    * Clock wise (advancing ~sec) Counter clock wise (tumble ~0.1sec) Organism Kilometers per hour Body lengths per second Cheetah 111 25 Human - Michael Johnson 37.5 5.4 Bacteria 0.00018 25 Bacteria find their way up a nutrient gradient by changing...
  • Map to Greenville Site Operations from I-85

    Map to Greenville Site Operations from I-85

    Head south on Main St. At the intersection of River St., veer LEFT onto Augusta St. ... As you approach the security gate, turn RIGHT just before the gate. ... 244 Terminal Road. Greenville, SC 29605. Arriving at Lockheed Martin...
  • symposia.gerad.ca

    symposia.gerad.ca

    The State Power Corporation (SPC) -- , was dismantled into two power grid firms, five generation groups and four auxiliary firms. Then we have to know the history of unbundling reform in China. The unbundling reform in China's electricity sector...
  • Technical Meeting Rundown Technical Meeting Waktu Durasi Kegiatan

    Technical Meeting Rundown Technical Meeting Waktu Durasi Kegiatan

    Persyaratan Lomba. Tiap timberanggotakan 2 orang dari sekolah yang sama. Peserta merupakan WNI dan belum pernah tinggal di Jepang lebih dari 6 bulan.