Disclosing and Suppressing Evidence - Cengage

Disclosing and Suppressing Evidence Chapter 12 1 Discovery The informal and formal exchange of information between prosecution and defense. Seeks to ensure that the adversary system does not give one side an unfair advantage

over the other. No general constitutional right to discovery in a criminal case. (Weatherford v. Bursey) 2 The Prosecutor and the Discovery Process Jencks v. U.S.: prior inconsistent statements of a witness must be made available to defense counsel. Brady v. Maryland: due process of law is violated when prosecutors conceal evidence that might be favorable to the defense (applies only to

exculpatory evidence). U.S. v. Agnus: Prosecutor need only disclose evidence under Brady if it would have been persuasive and produced reasonable doubt about guilt. 3 Reciprocal Disclosure Defense counsel does not have to abide by the same disclosure rules as prosecutor. In most jurisdictions, defense counsel must disclose:

Alibi witnesses. Expert witnesses that are to be called. Whether the defendant is planning on relying upon the defense of insanity, diminished responsibility, entrapment, or self-defense. 4 Exclusionary Rule Prohibits the prosecutor from using illegally obtained evidence during a trial. Three exclusionary rules: Identification of suspects (line-ups).

Confessions. Searches and seizures. 5 Fifth Amendment No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury...; nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in a criminal case to be

witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without the due process of law... 6 Coerced Confessions Brown v. Mississippi: Use of physical coercion to obtain confessions violates the due process clause of the 14th Amendment. Ashcraft v. Tennessee: Psychologically coerced confessions are not voluntary and therefore not admissible in court.

7 Miranda v. Arizona If a suspect is in custody and the police are interrogating him, the police must first tell him: You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in an court of law. You have the right to talk to a lawyer and have him/her present with you while you are being questioned. If you cannot afford to hire a lawyer, one will be

appointed to represent you before any questioning, if you wish. 8 Exceptions to Miranda: Voluntary statements Public Safety Exception

Consent (Waiving of your rights) Spontaneous declarations 9 Miranda Jurisprudence

Harris v. New York New York v. Quarles Davis v. U.S. Texas v. Cobb Minnick v. Mississippi Dickerson v. U.S. 10 Fourth Amendment The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against

unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath and affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized. 11 The Exclusionary Rule and the Fourth Amendment Prohibits the prosecutor from using illegally obtained evidence during a trial.

Weeks v. U.S.: established the exclusionary rule for federal prosecutions. Mapp v. Ohio: Extended the exclusionary rule to the states. 12 Exclusionary Rule Jurisprudence Illinois v. Wardlow: A person running at the sight of a police officer could justify a stop-and-frisk. U.S. v. Drayton: Police officers do not have to advise suspects of their right not to consent to a

search. Kyllo v. U.S.: Police may not use a thermal imaging device to detect the presence of high-intensity lamps used to grow marijuana. Florida v. J.L.: Police cant stop and search a person for a gun solely on the basis of an anonymous tip. 13 Search Warrants Search Warrants require Probable Cause. Signed affidavits by police.

Issuance by a Judge or magistrate. A specific description of the person/place/things, etc., to be searched and seized. 14 Search and Seizure Jurisprudence Terry v. Ohio: Police officers may conduct a frisk of the outer clothing on the basis of reasonable suspicion that a crime is being contemplated. Chimel v. California: In a search incident to

arrest, the police may search only the defendants person can the area within the immediate vicinity. U.S. v. Leon: Creates a limited good-faith exception. 15 More Search and Seizure Jurisprudence Illinois v. Krull: Good faith exception applied to a warrantless search, even when the state statute was late found to violate the Fourth Amendment.

Maryland v. Garrison: Evidence is admissible even though the specifics in the search warrant were inaccurate. Knowles v. Iowa: Issuing a speeding ticket does not give police authority to search the car. Arizona v. Evans: Evidence is admissible even though the specifics in the warrant were based on computer error. 16 Issues in Search and Seizure Law in a Nutshell

Stop and Frisk Pat-downs Good Faith Exception Public Safety Exception

Expectations of Privacy Exigent Circumstances Arms Length Rule 17 Warrantless Searches Consent

Plain View Incident to Lawful Arrest Vehicle Searches: Probable Cause Consent Plain view 18 Suppression Hearings Motions by defense to suppress certain evidence that the defense believes was gleaned illegally. Usually as a result of a violation of the suspects

4th or 5th Amendment rights. Judges hear the argument and make a ruling to grant or reject the motions. Usually not granted. Main witness offering testimony is the police officer. 19 20

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • SPM 200 Skills Lab 3

    SPM 200 Skills Lab 3

    Clinical Skills Lab 6 ... tube may be in the trachea Airway Anatomy Indications for Artificial Airways To relieve airway obstruction To facilitate removal of secretions To protect the lower airways for aspiration To facilitate the application of positive pressure...
  • A Prototype Energy Spectrometer for the ILC at

    A Prototype Energy Spectrometer for the ILC at

    UCL HEP Other titles: Times New Roman StarSymbol Arial Tahoma Symbol Blank Presentation Slide 1 ...
  • Your profession is your passion. Pass it on.

    Your profession is your passion. Pass it on.

    Times MS PGothic Lucida Grande Arial MS Pゴシック Wingdings Arial Black ヒラギノ角ゴ ProN W3 Blank Presentation 1_Blank Presentation Your profession is your passion. Pass it on.
  • Gene expression - Vigo County School Corporation

    Gene expression - Vigo County School Corporation

    Homeotic genes (Hox genes) ... Point mutation in either the promoter or the an enhancer that controls a proto-oncogene, causing an increase in its expression OR a point mutation in the coding sequence changing the gene's protduct to a protein...
  • Mark Rothko - Teachers.Henrico Webserver

    Mark Rothko - Teachers.Henrico Webserver

    Mark Rothko Abstract Expressionism Untitled 1968 Mark Rothko in his studio c.1964 Mark Rothko, as a result of being physically ill and suffering from depression, committed suicide on February 25, 1970. At the time of his death, he was widely...
  • midsunschool.weebly.com


    Men were sometimes Hoyaneh, leaders of the Haudenosaunee. Men also were the hunters and the gatherers. They also protected the clan from harm and went to war. They also accepted the great law of peace. Roles of Haudenosaunee women? Women...
  • Page 1  Grace mieszka w Sudanie. Jej mama,

    Page 1 Grace mieszka w Sudanie. Jej mama,

    Page 2 Images courtesy: www.practicalaction.org.uk małe opakowanie po jogurcie kostka lodu doniczka mokry piasek Co dzieje się z każdą z tych kostek lodu? pokrywka Page 3 Myślę, że kostka lodu w podwójnej donicy zacznie się rozpuszczać szybciej, ponieważ dodatkowa warstwa...
  • cpb-ca-c1.wpmucdn.com


    The Queen fears that Snow White's beauty surpasses her own, so she forces Snow White to work as a scullery maid and asks her Magic Mirror daily "who is the fairest one of all". For several years the mirror always...